You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
Re: GnR holding audititons for a replacement for Robin?
buzzsaw wrote:Estranged may be the most underrated song in rock history.
Every so often (maybe on a long ride home at night or something) I'll be listening to Estranged alone and it will really hit me. That song is fucking amazing.
And I really wish they'd have done it with Robin in the band. As you all know, I'm sure he'd have played it even better.
I KID, I KID
Oh God I'm feeling nausea coming up. To each his own I guess.
Re: GnR holding audititons for a replacement for Robin?
axlin - you make some good points but i find some similarities between nr and twat. they both suck until they hit the the outro. the last couple minutes of these two songs are some of the best gnr has to offer from any album.
neemo- you also make some good points but i would never call the vocals in til boradway. just because the rasp is not always there doesn't mean it's broadway.
madagas - i agree that the til lyrics are as true if not more true (which i would lean on) than estranged but i'd give the nod to estranged lyrics being better written. it's like a trade off for axl. if i say exactly what i'm felling it'll be really heavy but i'll also come off sounding like a 16 year old girl.
Re: GnR holding audititons for a replacement for Robin?
Estranged is the shit...all Gnr fans know that. Somebody needs to start a discussion going on the Axl piano epics. Only use Estranged, Breakdown, TIL, and NR....those four because those 4 are the only piano Axl tracks where he gets sole writing credits. TWAT and Prostitute have co-writers so don't include them.
