Board footer

Roxxie

 Rep: 11 

Re: Rate it?!

Roxxie wrote:

9.  It's not perfect, but seeing as I enjoy it over pretty much anything else that's around now I can't rate it any lower!

Axlin16

 Rep: 768 

Re: Rate it?!

Axlin16 wrote:

9/10

It's a masterpiece, and worth the wait, but 'perfect'... eh, not quite.

war

 Rep: 108 

Re: Rate it?!

war wrote:

8.5 and i don't think this is only the best of the best

we were told several of these tracks were not going to be on the album and all of the sudden all of the leaked tracks are on the album.

at some point axl had to decide if he wanted a masterpiece or if he wanted a couple great albums

hopefully, there will be album 2 at some point

Communist China

 Rep: 130 

Re: Rate it?!

Communist China wrote:

Who gave it a 1? Or a 3?

James

 Rep: 664 

Re: Rate it?!

James wrote:

I'm sticking with the 6 I gave it in my review. It has some killer songs, but its bogged down by mediocre mixing and a bit of filler.

NY Giants82

 Rep: 26 

Re: Rate it?!

NY Giants82 wrote:

9

I love it, and think its great.

gnfnraxl

 Rep: 43 

Re: Rate it?!

gnfnraxl wrote:

I give it a 7.  Would've been an 8 or 9 if Finck hadn't butchered CITR.

2008 Intentions

 Rep: 6 

Re: Rate it?!

2008 Intentions wrote:

10, maybe is because the last 6 or 7 years there only good cds and a loooooooooooooot of sh!t

Bono

 Rep: 386 

Re: Rate it?!

Bono wrote:

I'm sticking with my 6 rating as well. It has 5 really awesome songs but way too many boring to average at best to some real shitty songs.  Not to mention questionable production. 6 outta 10 is fair I think coming from me.

Sky Dog

Re: Rate it?!

Sky Dog wrote:

8....1 point deduction for Shackler and a 1 point reduction for some clutter throughout.