You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
Re: Robin back in NIN. Temp or not is the question?
war wrote:Neemo wrote:Robin even then though was the guitarist with the most leads...bumble basically was basically doing the same parts as BH had before....from what i remember...though i dont recall bh doing the rhythm stuff much
hey gimme a break it was 6 years ago...i went to Toronto both times BTW
both shows were great, weren't they?
oh yeah but still they were different....02 seemed to be more volatile...more electric....06 seemed stable and energetic
whats shows have you been to since this CD rollercoaster ride began?
'02 and '06 minneapolis minnesota
'02 was terrbile - upper deck rear stadium no sound coming out of the rear speakers. it was like listening to the radio on a crappy stereo with static
the only things i took from it were bucket's solo and axl's vocals on 'i think about you
'06 was amazing
Re: Robin back in NIN. Temp or not is the question?
I agree that a Finck departure is a major blow to the CD era fanbase. He is the one that the younger gen of fans(and some older as well) identify with in that role. Love him or hate him, Finck leaving creates a void that will be difficult to fulfill.
However, there's a pot on my stove that's cooking, and it smells like a reunion.
Axl hires new management
VR implode
Finck's status up in the air and not available for at LEAST a year
Other CD era members doing their own projects
Do the math.
Slash did say they played with a new singer, but wouldn't hint as to who. Doubtful that it's Axl, but with new management and VR imploding, there's a very small chance. If they played with him, we had better brace ourselves.
- Jimmy Zig Zag Bobiadis
- Rep: 25
Re: Robin back in NIN. Temp or not is the question?
there is no way in hell a lame ass reunion is going to happen. axl is not going to sell out the band just to bring in a bunch of guys who abandoned it a long time ago and don't deserve to be in the band.
Re: Robin back in NIN. Temp or not is the question?
there is no way in hell a lame ass reunion is going to happen. axl is not going to sell out the band just to bring in a bunch of guys who abandoned it a long time ago and don't deserve to be in the band.
JB, its passed being in "lame ass" mode and "selling out" or "abandonment".
Pandora's Box has just been opened, and NO ONE knows how its gonna turn out.
Axl hires new management, VR implodes with Weiland ranting that the VR bandmates were "covering up the truth", and Finck all of a sudden decides to do a world tour with NIN.
All this happened in the span of about a week regarding people who go YEARS without doing or saying anything.
Coincidence?
I think not.
JB, you've known me quite a long time and I have always wanted CD and a followup album over a reunion any day of the week.
But its time for everyone to look at the reality of the situation. We may be seeing the implosion of the CD era right before our very eyes.
Re: Robin back in NIN. Temp or not is the question?
Truth is, I was ready to play the reunion card when Weiland first started flying off the handle and then the NIN tour dates went out with a mysterious "reunion" within that band. I'm surprised it took some of you this long to start doing the simple mathematics.
Re: Robin back in NIN. Temp or not is the question?
if finck leaves, now even the harcore fans of the new band won´t support this mess anymore (after the hardcore fans of the old gnr stopped 10 years ago obviously...)
''
Can't speak for everyone else, but it will takes a lot to get me back onboard for another line up change. I saw GNR as a band consisting of Axl and a core of song writers and contributors in Finck, Stinson and Dizzy. The rest could be replaced (after BH left). Now the core is also breaking up and I can hardly imagine this as a band anymore.
But as for a reunion? Unless Slash and Duff just quits the whole VR thing (and if I may so do..please do, its crap anyway) you won't see a reunion and Axl is way to nice to his band mates to just leave them behind after 10 years with Stinson and Finck (although a bit on and off).
But, even I, a person who always looked at reunion posters as insane retards with a naive wet dream see this possibility looming somewhere in the background. With the recent events, it at least got a theoretical possibility of happening.
I couldnt agree more with Lafton on the other stuff though, people ain't taking this serious enough. You just saw the whole of 2008 blow up in your face and people are being naive enough to think they can still release and album or even tour with Finck in 2008. 2008 gone is your best case scenario. 2009 gone too isn't far off in the distance if you ask me.
- Jimmy Zig Zag Bobiadis
- Rep: 25
Re: Robin back in NIN. Temp or not is the question?
Jimmy Zig Zag Bobiadis wrote:there is no way in hell a lame ass reunion is going to happen. axl is not going to sell out the band just to bring in a bunch of guys who abandoned it a long time ago and don't deserve to be in the band.
JB, its passed being in "lame ass" mode and "selling out" or "abandonment".
Pandora's Box has just been opened, and NO ONE knows how its gonna turn out.
Axl hires new management, VR implodes with Weiland ranting that the VR bandmates were "covering up the truth", and Finck all of a sudden decides to do a world tour with NIN.
All this happened in the span of about a week regarding people who go YEARS without doing or saying anything.
Coincidence?
I think not.
JB, you've known me quite a long time and I have always wanted CD and a followup album over a reunion any day of the week.
But its time for everyone to look at the reality of the situation. We may be seeing the implosion of the CD era right before our very eyes.
its a pipe dream. none of that stuff points to a reunion happening. its just not gonna happen. i'll put money on it.
if it did, i would seriously delete every account on every GnR forum. it would be absolute bullshit, and thats why I know its not gonna happen.
