Board footer

RussTCB

 Rep: 633 

Re: UYI vs CD vs AFD

RussTCB wrote:

removed

monkeychow

 Rep: 661 

Re: UYI vs CD vs AFD

monkeychow wrote:

Ok...if we HAVE to cut CD down to 12 tracks...

Cue Controversy:

I'd cut out Sorry and Prostitute.

I like prostitute but to me it feels like the only song on CD that still sounds demoish - the synth stuff is amazing - but the guitar solo doesn't do it for me.

Sorry - well I dunno...can't understand why it seems to be most people's favourite. It's a nice song and all..but to me it's the weakest on the album. But that's just me I guess.

monkeychow

 Rep: 661 

Re: UYI vs CD vs AFD

monkeychow wrote:

Oh wait were we supossed to pick between AFD - a shortened UYI or a 12 track CD....

I can't do that!!! What the fuck!!!

That's like asking me to choose between pussy, ass and tits. I'd explain which album is which....but it would turn bad!

RussTCB

 Rep: 633 

Re: UYI vs CD vs AFD

RussTCB wrote:

removed

Sky Dog

Re: UYI vs CD vs AFD

Sky Dog wrote:

12 tracks each so the album gets "tighter" with less filler. Most think the 12 AFD tracks are perfect so it's on it's own.

and man up Monkey, you have to choose.

Neemo

 Rep: 485 

Re: UYI vs CD vs AFD

Neemo wrote:

to narrow down CD i'd have to remove Prostitute and This I Love

a 12 track UYI would look like this for me
   
Dust N' Bones   
Don't Cry
Perfect Crime
November Rain
Don't Damn Me
Dead Horse
Civil War
14 Years
Breakdown
Pretty Tied Up
Estranged
You Could Be Mine

Sky Dog

Re: UYI vs CD vs AFD

Sky Dog wrote:

I would definitely drop Shackler's and then probably Street of Dreams since it really sounds like a song the original band would have done. I like it but it seems a little out of place.

Sky Dog

Re: UYI vs CD vs AFD

Sky Dog wrote:

actually, SOD and TIL sound like old band songs so leave Shackler's and you have this....

Chinese Democracy
Shackler's Revenge
Better
If The World
There Was A Time
Catcher In The Rye
Scraped
Riad N' The Bedouins
Sorry
I.R.S.
Madagascar
Prostitute

all these tracks are pretty new band sounding..imo

Neemo

 Rep: 485 

Re: UYI vs CD vs AFD

Neemo wrote:

actually if i can use OMG then i woiuld drop SR, TIL and Prostitute and add that in

Chinese Democracy
Better
Street of Dreams
If The World
There Was A Time
Catcher In The Rye
Scraped
Riad N' The Bedouins
Sorry
I.R.S.
Madagascar
Oh My God

buzzsaw

 Rep: 423 

Re: UYI vs CD vs AFD

buzzsaw wrote:

If I had to do cd, I would take every version of twat out there and mix in some of the better demos. If that didn't fill it, I'd mix my world in to keep with the theme. Yes, I like my world more than most of cd. I don't hate it at all and find it somewhat humorous.