You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
Re: from mister saint laurent
madagas wrote:thanks...either way...meh. Who the fuck would pay $ for that?
So what's your take on it....Live Era or 99 AFD?
Definitely agree with Madagas. If Axl ever released this stuff "for money officially" he would be laughed at even more. I could see it as a bonus CD for a new album or in a box set, but absolutely nothing more than that. Only listened to the clip a couple times, but it came across to me as AFD with the balls missing. Really sounds neutered.
It personally sounds like 99 AFD to me. Live Era sounds like more of an original live performance, that was tweaked with the 99 AFD masters, but not fully. Particularly Axl's vocals. I think the instrumentation was most noticeably tweaked with Sweet Child O' Mine, and that's probably because the song was released on the soundtrack to a big film. You know how paranoid Axl is about how stuff sounds.
Either way, thanks to you and Neemo.
Re: from mister saint laurent
Live Era.
Although, judging from the way Axl pasted his old Catcher vocals over the top of the new version, it is possible the re-recorded vocals used in Live Era have been lifted from the so called re-recorded Appetite.
But didnt Axl say that it was nothing more than a DAT tape ? I dont think this 99 AFD really exists in an album form, it just rehearsals of the then new band captured on tape.
- elevendayempire
- Rep: 96
- elevendayempire
- Rep: 96
Re: from mister saint laurent
Cheers m'dears. It's... interesting. More like the actual AFD I was expecting, given the differences between the original SCOM and the Big Daddy version. I suppose we'd have to hear a solo to pick up on the real differences.
- monkeychow
- Rep: 661
Re: from mister saint laurent
Instrumentation sounds live to me...although as said above - that could be cos it's a dat tape and not properly mixed etc. I also think the cuts are suspicious....cuts off right before moments in the song that could be tell tale which version it came from.....my guess is fake made to get something else.
Re: from mister saint laurent
mix sounds odd like not together. vocals sound like live era. if thats re recorded appetite demo or not i am not impressed. i know this is opinion but feels alot like fact. nothing will top what was the 1987 released original appetite. don't care who plays on it. original members or anyone else.
