You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
Re: Who REALLY wrote Chinese Democracy
...Of course Mark Canter, knows alot less about Pre "AFD" Gn'R, than you.
Using fucked up logic in a losing argument. Maybe all the boards should shut down since Slash knows more than any of us.
That's your comeback line...
Hmmmmm...
Re: Who REALLY wrote Chinese Democracy
Works written by:
TOBIAS PAUL H Society: ASCAP CAE/IPI No. 334.24.59.74
1 . BACK OFF BITCH
(Title Code: 320373851)
2 . CATCHER IN THE RYE
(Title Code: 334474378)
3 . CHINESE DEMOCRACY
(Title Code: 334393698)
4 . I.R.S.
(Title Code: 393950199)
5 . JUNKIE
(Title Code: 400272308)
6 . OH MY GOD
(Title Code: 450485146)
7 . PROSTITUTE
(Title Code: 463436497)
8 . RIAD N' THE BEDOUINS
(Title Code: 482479334)
9 . SHADOW OF YOUR LOVE
(Title Code: 490851844)
10 . SHOTGUN MARY
(Title Code: 491520468)
11 . STREET OF DREAMS
(Title Code: 497227195)
12 . THERE WAS A TIME
(Title Code: 506275776)
Re: Who REALLY wrote Chinese Democracy
"Anything Goes"
"Shadow Of Your Love"
"Oh My God"
-Some of "Lies" Demos
"Reckless Life"
"Move To The City"
-Several of the "Use Your Illusion" Demos
"Back Off Bitch"
"Don't Cry"
"November Rain"
?
Were not originally recorded by Slash...
I'm skipping the "Chinese Democracy" part...
Re: Who REALLY wrote Chinese Democracy
James Lofton wrote:...Of course Mark Canter, knows alot less about Pre "AFD" Gn'R, than you.
Using fucked up logic in a losing argument. Maybe all the boards should shut down since Slash knows more than any of us.
That's your comeback line...
Hmmmmm...
I basically said the same thing as you to show you the absurdity of it. If you have a problem with it, go look in the mirror.
Couple of other juicy nuggets from the mind of atarilegend and apparently Marc Canter as well.....
Tobias played on the original demos, Slash did re-do it in his own style... but he was for the most part playing parts already created by some one else
Creativity is creating the music not playing it.
Played the original/created the guitar parts. If we went by who has credit on a sleeve as the song writer... Axl would un-doubly be the greatest multi-instrumentalist of all time.
I think you'd jump off a bridge if the end result was Slash losing a few songwriting credits.
"Anything Goes"
"Shadow Of Your Love"James Lofton wrote:-Some of "Lies" Demos
"Reckless Life"
"Move To The City"James Lofton wrote:-Several of the "Use Your Illusion" Demos
"Back Off Bitch"
"Don't Cry"
"November Rain"?
Were not originally recorded by Slash...
I'm skipping the "Chinese Democracy" part...
You forgot to list half of AFD. No one on this planet but you is gonna give him credit for Don't Cry and NR.
I'm not gonna give him credit for those other songs either.
Go reread those ASCAP credits you just posted for reference.
Re: Who REALLY wrote Chinese Democracy
You forgot to list half of AFD.
I'm not gonna give him credit for those other songs either.
Go reread those ASCAP credits you just posted for reference.
-Half of the "Appetite For Destruction" Demos
-Most of "Lies"
-3/4 of "Use Your Illusion" Demos[/i]
I removed that part, after I posted an actual list of tracks. You quoted something I had the to delete myself months ago. Well played.
Re: Who REALLY wrote Chinese Democracy
The contents of this thread are hilarious
We've went from not giving Axl enough credit to giving Slash too much credit, and now apparently Tobias was the mastermind of GNR.
I like Tobias. For years I have wanted him to come back. I just think its insane that some people try and diminish what the original line up contributed.
Re: Who REALLY wrote Chinese Democracy
I removed that part, after I posted an actual list of tracks. You quoted something I had the sense to remove myself months ago. Well played.
So I'm lacking sense over something YOU posted? Apparently you weren't very confident in his contributions. 
You should request that Tobias hire you as an attorney. He has tens of millions of dollars waiting for him in revenue from all these shadow writing credits.
He should be edited in to all the old videos and Slash removed.
