You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
Re: Best album of the 90s elimination- Round 15
Was eliminated in the last round.
Was gonna vote off UYI II, but after skimming through Dirt, I'm gonna have to vote for Dirt. Does UYI II have filler? Does a bear shit in the woods? However, the strong tracks on UYI II are superior to Dirt as a whole. If it was Facelift on this list instead of Dirt, I'd vote off UYI II without hesitation.
- NY Giants82
- Rep: 26
Re: Best album of the 90s elimination- Round 15
Superunknown
Whew, this is getting tough. I came very close to going for Ten.
Dirt is among my favorites up there. It's a virtual tie with the UYI albums imo AND the Black album. I might would only give a slight advantage to UYI I, simply because of the presence of Dead Horse & Coma on the tail end of that album. If you subtract some of that filler in the back end of UYI I, and replace it with Dead Horse & Coma... there's certaintly enough power there to take on that amazing finale to Dirt with Hate To Feel, Angry Chair & Would?
Illusion filler is better than Dirt filler, but not by much. Black album filler crushed both of them imo. Not much filler on that album at all. There's not much filler on Superunknown or Ten.
This is truely now a popularity contest. It's coming down to personal preference, because ALL of those albums up there are fuckin' masterpieces.
- jimmythegent
- Rep: 30
Re: Best album of the 90s elimination- Round 15
woah, looks like what I consider the best 90s rock album (superunknown) is in trouble
Dirt again for me
