You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
Re: GnREvolution Chinese Democracy Elimination 2015 - Round 3
I voted Shackler's. That 2nd verse kills the flow of the album. Would have voted off Catcher in The Rye for the Ron's rape of Brian May and my ears, but I think certain people are confusing both versions 
and it'd be a wasted vote.
Crazy that "This I Love" is probably going to go, it's like waving a red flag in front of a bull. Except audiences like it, I don't think this is going to be representative of non forum users. Not to say that it's my favorite track, but crazy to say it's one of the worst.
- A Private Eye
- Rep: 77
Re: GnREvolution Chinese Democracy Elimination 2015 - Round 3
CITR. A beautiful song turned into noise pollution. Had CD not been a leaks album I don't think it would have been on the album. At least I hope not.
Once a few more turds get flushed this is going to get difficult. I'm glad I took a year's long break from CD. The nails on a chalkboard vibe has lessened.
Re: GnREvolution Chinese Democracy Elimination 2015 - Round 3
omg tho i am split on a few of them. dont hate it but its the others have no votes lol
james, how do you vote off catcher when, even with the overproduction, it is such a well written song.
if you cant polish a turd and come up with a gem
then
you cant overpolish a gem and come up with a turd
lol
Re: GnREvolution Chinese Democracy Elimination 2015 - Round 3
james, how do you vote off catcher when, even with the overproduction, it is such a well written song.
This is just my opinion. If There Was A Time was re-recorded with nails on a chalk board instead of Bucket's solo, it'd still be a well written song. It's just that it'd be fucking painful, which isn't much different to what Ron did to Catcher.
Re: GnREvolution Chinese Democracy Elimination 2015 - Round 3
war wrote:james, how do you vote off catcher when, even with the overproduction, it is such a well written song.
This is just my opinion. If There Was A Time was re-recorded with nails on a chalk board instead of Bucket's solo, it'd still be a well written song. It's just that it'd be fucking painful, which isn't much different to what Ron did to Catcher.
i actually think catcher is a better written song than twat.
twat has better guitar peformance on it and that is what everyone always states as the reason for liking the song, along with axl's screams.
take away twats solo and axls screams and what do you really have? a decent song imo. the chorus and versus are nothing speial IMO.
catcher is still recognized as a good song by most even with the shitty solo and overproduction.
add slash or bucket to catcher and keep twat teh same id put them neck to neck, objectively, and still prefer catcher, personally.
Re: GnREvolution Chinese Democracy Elimination 2015 - Round 3
"This I Love," for the third consecutive time. It's cheese. "Oh My God" is the best of this whole lot, save maybe "Better." And "Shackler's Revenge" is a beast and it's getting an awful lot of hate. Too bad. I guess my tastes run very contrary to the majority here.
