You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
- IRISH OS1R1S
- Rep: 59
Re: Who's DJ?
His credibility was threatened when he said Axl fired Slash. No, Slash quit, per his own admission, and Axl tried for quite awhile to get him back, before he became a "cancer".
Two, Buckethead is in Robin's shadow... lmao. This is where he lost ALL credibility. Nobody is in Bucket's shadow on CD. In fact - Bucket makes CD, and even Ron's best solos in some places were originally written by Bucket. Robin adds absolutely nothing, and shockingly (yes, I was shocked by this, seeing how he was a 'lead guitarist' with the project from day one), Robin is suprisingly lost on the record, rarely coming up with anything significant past the song Better, for which he gets a writing credit. This I Love is the only other thing I can think of, and his solo being turned up over the great orchestra, seemed like Axl simply trying to find a way to let a band member shine, even though it should've been reversed, orchestra up front, solo in the back.
There's no reason to go on and on about Robin. If you want, I suggest going to the There Was A Time section for former employees, or visit a NIN board, his active band.
the "great orchestra" as you call it, is great. yeah. it's great. you know why? it's "filler." you know what else? without robin's epic solo all over it..TIL would be filler too. that's credible
Re: Who's DJ?
Robin single-handedly takes new Guns "November Rain" and rapes it with his really godawful guitar solo.
Now i've tried to be nice in past discussions, that turning up the orchestra, and backing it with the guitar solo, is something that works to please everyone, but frankly, the piece of shit solo should've either been redone by Bucket, or more likely, been removed altogether.
And I agree BLS, Bucket's solo on Sorry is great. TWAT too.
Re: Who's DJ?
I listend to the album for the first time in a long time tonight and honestly I think Robin's solo on This I Love is the best solo on the album and is one of the album's highlights. At the very least it has the most emotion of any solo on the album. I like it. In fact I would go as far as to say Robin's solo actually saves that song. It's not that great in my opinion untill Robin's solo kicks in.
On a side note 7 months after it's release I think Prostitute is by far the best song on the album
Re: Who's DJ?
Man i love this thread lol.
robin67 wrote:
"i heard axl bumps beta over and over ":laugh:
I like almost everything on CD. TIL would be good with or without the robin-playing like slash solo. but thats just my opinion
I liked robins work
better DJ to replace him than that hanson kid ?
http://
Re: Who's DJ?
I listend to the album for the first time in a long time tonight and honestly I think Robin's solo on This I Love is the best solo on the album and is one of the album's highlights. At the very least it has the most emotion of any solo on the album. I like it. In fact I would go as far as to say Robin's solo actually saves that song. It's not that great in my opinion untill Robin's solo kicks in.
On a side note 7 months after it's release I think Prostitute is by far the best song on the album
Prostitute and TWAT are my faves.
As for Robin, my fave solo is his TWAT solo....I hear alot of emotion in that one.:cool:
Re: Who's DJ?
"axl's a troll. he's trolling the grounds on his billion dollar estate"
"i heard axl bumps beta over and over "
:haha::haha::haha::haha:
These are my favourite quotes to ever come out of any GN'R forum.
robin67, could you please list your favourite parts of CD?
robin's TIL solo
robin's better solo
robin's TWAT solo
robin's SOD solo
robin's chinese democracy solo
robin's catcher n' the rye solo
robin's irs solo
everything n' anything robin on cd
