You are not logged in. Please register or login.
- Topics: Active | Unanswered
- tejastech08
- Rep: 194
Re: Perhaps (2023) to Drop
Sounds like new vocals. Guess that was more than a sound check and Axl was singing
I don't think it's new vocals. Sounds identical to the old leak from 4-5 years ago, just better quality on the new release. Maybe added some effects to the vocal, but it's still the same voice from 20+ years ago at the core of the song.
- tejastech08
- Rep: 194
Re: Perhaps (2023) to Drop
Any "new" vocals on any of these songs are more than likely from 2006-7...or "flown in" from other songs.
Again...I'm ok with it.
I don't think we would want to hear a "new" version of it. Axl's voice is gone these days. Whatever was left of it, I think he used it all on the AC/DC gigs in 2016.
Re: Perhaps (2023) to Drop
misterID wrote:Sounds like new vocals. Guess that was more than a sound check and Axl was singing
I don't think it's new vocals. Sounds identical to the old leak from 4-5 years ago, just better quality on the new release. Maybe added some effects to the vocal, but it's still the same voice from 20+ years ago at the core of the song.
The outro vocals are different. There’s def added vocals in the chorus. I could be wrong, but either they were way enhanced or new. Idk, I’m picking up different melodies in the tone at certain points than in the demo.
A studio voice is much different than a live voice
- elevendayempire
- Rep: 96
Re: Perhaps (2023) to Drop
Sounds like new vocals. Guess that was more than a sound check and Axl was singing
It is possible that he did multiple vocal takes in the 90s/00s, y'know…
Re: Perhaps (2023) to Drop
His *newest* vocals were Rock the Rock and he sounded great. I don’t know why it’s a stretch to think he couldn’t do it on these recordings. Hard Skool used those early vocals and you can tell
He had a killer rasp on his Live Era/Big Daddy vocal recordings but never sang that way live around that time.
- elevendayempire
- Rep: 96
Re: Perhaps (2023) to Drop
His *newest* vocals were Rock the Rock and he sounded great. I don’t know why it’s a stretch to think he couldn’t do it on these recordings. Hard Skool used those early vocals and you can tell
He had a killer rasp on his Live Era/Big Daddy vocal recordings but never sang that way live around that time.
Oh yeah, I don't deny that he's perfectly capable of laying down studio vocals now, it's just that it's become an article of faith among GN'R fans that he laid down a single vocal take for each song back in 1999 or whatever, and that he never recorded anything else. Which is insane; of course there are multiple vocal takes in the vaults.
