You are not logged in. Please register or login.

Me_Wise_Magic
 Rep: 70 

Re: Favorite Gnr Song From Each Album

Myles sings great on Paradise & Sweet Child in my opinion. Some other cuts not so much!

Son of a Gun
 Rep: -3 

Re: Favorite Gnr Song From Each Album

Son of a Gun wrote:

Fave songs from each album:
AFD -- Rocket Queen
GNR Lies --- One In A Million
UYi I --- Coma
UYI II --- Civil War too much fillers on Illusion II
TSI ---- Pass
CD --- Better honorouble mentiions TWAT, CITR,Prostitude


Least Fave songs :
AFD --- Anything Goes
Lies ---- Reckless Life
UYI I ---- You Ain`t the First
UYI II --- GITR followed by Shotgun Blues
CD ----- If the World

Re: Favorite Gnr Song From Each Album

imsorry wrote:

least favorites:

AFD - You're Crazy
Lies - None
UYI I - Bad Apples
UYI II - My World
TSI - I Don't Care About You
CD - I would say none but CiTR and Riad (thanks Bumblefoot for his horrendous work) but i love the demo's.

bucket

tejastech08
 Rep: 194 

Re: Favorite Gnr Song From Each Album

tejastech08 wrote:
Axlin12 wrote:

I have to be in a positive feeling towards love to "get into" Sweet Child. It's a song so overplayed and beat into the ground by everyone else other than GN'R than I just don't like associate myself with it. It might be their cheesiest effort from that period.

I really don't care too much about the lyrics. To me it's just cool to hear the musical talent on display. That song might be one of the best mixes they ever did. You can easily hear every band member's contributions and they all sound great.

polluxlm
 Rep: 221 

Re: Favorite Gnr Song From Each Album

polluxlm wrote:

I'm bored too so I've compiled you guys answers into a list.

First thing I noticed is to just pick one favorite song from each album is fucking hard! Most of these I had to flip a coin on to avoid feeling guilty.

Rocket Queen (drew lots from Jungle, Nightrain, PC, SCOM and RQ)

One In A Million (coin on that and Crazy)

Coma (coin on that and DDM)

Estranged

Down On The Farm (drew lots from that and SIDHY, AIF, HOTD and IDCABY)

Catcher In The Rye (coin on that and TWAT)

The list according to GN'R Evo:

Appetite For Destruction

Rocket Queen 8
Welcome To The Jungle 5
Sweet Child O Mine 4
Nightrain 4
Mr Brownstone 2
It's So Easy 2
Paradise City 1

GN'R Lies

One In A Million 15
You're Crazy 7
Patience 2
Move To The City 2

Use Your Illusion I

Coma 14
November Rain 2
Double Talking Jive 2
Dead Horse 2
The Garden 2
Dust N Bones 2
Don't Cry 1
Don't Damn Me 1

Use Your Illusion II

Estranged 14
You Could Be Mine 5
Pretty Tied Up 2
Civil War 2
Breakdown 2
Locomotive 1

The Spaghetti Incident?

Down On The Farm 7
Ain't It Fun 6
Human Being 4
Black Leather 2
Hair Of The Dog 2
Look At Your Game Girl 1
Since I Don't Have You 1

Chinese Democracy

There Was A Time 12
Madagascar 3
Better 3
Prostitute 2
Chinese Democracy 2
Riad And The Bedouins 1
This I Love 1
Catcher In The Rye 1

As you can see we can draw some interesting conclusions from this list.

Most popular song (on a single album): One In A Million
Album(s) with the most favorites: UYI 1 and CD
Most even spread: AFD and TSI

faldor
 Rep: 281 

Re: Favorite Gnr Song From Each Album

faldor wrote:

Nice work!  Always interesting to look at the breakdown of polls.

Axlin16
 Rep: 768 

Re: Favorite Gnr Song From Each Album

Axlin16 wrote:

Wow, it's really all over the place. I think that's got to do with the diehard, analytical fanbase we have here.

Bono
 Rep: 386 

Re: Favorite Gnr Song From Each Album

Bono wrote:

Interesting stuff. This thread is from 6 weeks ago and I immediately thought of the Top 10 GnR songs thread in the ex Guns section. Made wonder if my Top 10 list was consistent with my picks in this thread.

For the most part they were. The only songs from this list that conflicted with the ranking of my Top 10 list were November Rain and Dead Horse. I had picked Dead Horse as my favourite off UYI I in this thread but ranked November Rain as my 3rd all time favourite Gn'R song in the other thread. Dead Horse though was the only other UYI I song to crack my top 10 all time list so these two songs seem to flip based on my mood. However I will say in the overall scheme of things and based on ALL TIME I'd have to go with November Rain as my consistent favourite off UYI 1.

here's what I said of the two songs in the other thread and where I ranked them.

Bono - In Top 10 All Time Thread wrote:

3. November Rain:
This charts fairly high on my list based on it's super nostalgia power. This song more than any Gn'R song takes me back to highschool. Not just school dances but everything. Back then it was THE song and again like SCOM the lyrics may be a tad soft but Slash's guitar solos are again the highlight and power the song. The outro to the song is the most unexpeced outro to any song ever in my opinion and it only added to the sheer grandness of the song. This song was in fact my favourite song of all time for years and years even after highschool. It's dropped a bit the last decade but still classic.


9. Dead Horse:
In my opinion Gn'R's most classic rock sounding song. I love the way the intro kicks in and tempo of the song from there on out is great.  Musically it's not anything special in the Gn'R catelogue, Axl's voice is good, lyrics are alright but the result is greater than the sum of the parts. It's just always been one of my very favourite Gn'R tunes.

Bono - In Favourite Song Off Each Album Thread wrote:

UYI I: Dead Horse

Smoking Guns
 Rep: 330 

Re: Favorite Gnr Song From Each Album

Smoking Guns wrote:

AFD - PC
Lies - Patience
UYI - Coma
UYII - Estranged
SI - Down on the Farm/Ain't it fun, Tie
Live Era - Used to Love Her/Rocket Queen (Axl's best vocals ever on that outro and they were done in the studio in 1999)
Greatest Hits - SCOM
CD - If the World
Snakepit 1 - Beggers and Hanger On's/Back and Forth Again Tie
Snakepit 2 - Serial Killer
VR Contraband - You Got No Right
VR Libertad - Messages
Slash - Ghost
Slash Apocalyptic Love - Anastasia
Slash Live from Stoke - Rocket Queen

Rex
 Rep: 50 

Re: Favorite Gnr Song From Each Album

Rex wrote:

AFD -- Rocket Queen
GNR Lies --- Used To Love Her
UYI I --- Coma
UYI II --- Estranged
TSI ---- I really like Human Being, Raw Power, and I Don't Care About You..probably go with Human Being.
CD --- Probably CITR, with Better a close second.

Board footer

Powered by FluxBB