James Lofton wrote:

My problem is the stories themselves. They just weren't fleshed out enough, and the one that is(the chicks and the serial killer) is given to us in small doses.

I agree with this point, really it is the only thing I can say negative about the movie.  Otherwise I thought the movie was excellent.  By no means would I rate it the next TCM, Exorcist or Halloween (it's much more "campy" than "serious") but it is easily one of the best holiday-themed movies made and a great little flick in general, albeit a bit "tame" for the genre.

I liked all the stories outside of The Principal, it was a little weak.  The School Bus Massacre, Meet Sam and The Virgin were all good stuff.  Not a perfect movie but I would give it a solid 4/5 for what it is.